This legal update summarizes (a) the reporting requirements under Section 13 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (the “Exchange Act”), which are generally applicable to persons that own, or exercise investment discretion over accounts that own, publicly traded or exchange-listed equity securities, [1] and (b) the reporting requirements under Section 16 of the Exchange Act, which are applicable to persons considered to be “insiders” of public companies. While the persons subject to the reporting requirements under Section 13 and Section 16 (each, a “reporting person”) generally include both individuals and entities, this legal update focuses on the application of the reporting requirements to investment advisers and broker-dealers (each, a “securities firm”). This legal update also includes a summary of certain proposed rules under the Exchange Act that would impose additional reporting requirements if adopted, and concludes with a schedule of the filing deadlines under Sections 13 and 16 for 2023.
Under Section 13 of the Exchange Act, reports made to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) are filed on Schedule 13D, Schedule 13G, Form 13F, and Form 13H, each of which is discussed in more detail below. A securities firm (and, in some cases, its parent company or other control persons) generally will have a Section 13 reporting obligation if the firm directly or indirectly:
Section 16(a) of the Exchange Act requires that directors and officers of a company that has a class of securities registered under Section 12 of the Exchange Act (a “public company”), as well as persons who beneficially own more than 10% of any class of equity security which is registered under Section 12 of the Exchange Act (other than any exempted security), file reports with the SEC on Forms 3, 4, and 5. Under Section 16(b) of Exchange Act, each of these “insiders” may be liable for any “short-swing profits” (i.e., profits made from a sale or purchase of the public company’s securities made within less than six months of a matching purchase or sale). These obligations are discussed in more detail in Section 16: Reports of Directors, Officers, and Principal Stockholders below.
Schedules 13D and 13G: Reporting Significant Acquisitions and Ownership Positions
Sections 13(d) and 13(g) of the Exchange Act require any person or group of persons [2] who directly or indirectly acquires or has beneficial ownership [3] of more than 5% of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities (the “5% threshold”) to report such beneficial ownership on Schedule 13D or Schedule 13G, as appropriate. Under Rule 13d-3, “beneficial ownership” of a security means that a person has or shares the power, directly or indirectly, through any contract, arrangement, understanding, relationship or otherwise, (a) to vote or direct the voting of a security (“voting power”), or (b) to dispose of or direct the disposition of a security (“investment power”).
Both Schedule 13D and Schedule 13G require background information about the reporting persons and the Section 13(d) Securities listed on the schedule, including the name, address, and citizenship or place of organization of each reporting person, the amount of the securities beneficially owned and aggregate beneficial ownership percentage, and whether voting and investment power is held solely by the reporting persons or shared with others. Reporting persons that must report on Schedule 13D are also required to disclose a significant amount of additional information, including certain disciplinary events, the source and amount of funds or other consideration used to purchase the Section 13(d) Securities, the purpose of the acquisition, any plans to change or influence the control of the issuer, and a list of any transactions in the securities effected in the previous 60 days. A reporting person may use the less burdensome Schedule 13G if it meets certain criteria described below.
In determining whether a securities firm has crossed the 5% threshold with respect to a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities, [4] it must include the positions held in any proprietary accounts and the positions held in all discretionary client accounts that it manages (including any private or registered funds, accounts managed by or for principals and employees, and accounts managed for no compensation), and positions held in any accounts managed by the firm’s control persons (which may include certain officers and directors) for themselves, their spouses, and dependent children (including IRA and most trust accounts).
In general, Schedule 13G is available to any reporting person that falls within one of the following three categories:
Exempt Investors. A reporting person is an “Exempt Investor” if the reporting person beneficially owns more than 5% of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities at the end of a calendar year, but its acquisition of the securities is exempt under Section 13(d)(6) of the Exchange Act. For example, a person that acquired all of its Section 13(d) Securities prior to the issuer’s registration of such securities (or class of securities) under the Exchange Act, or acquired no more than 2% of the Section 13(d) Securities within a 12-month period, is considered to be an Exempt Investor and would be eligible to file reports on Schedule 13G.
Qualified Institutions. Along with certain other institutions listed under the Exchange Act, [5] a reporting person that is a registered investment adviser or broker-dealer may file a Schedule 13G as a “Qualified Institution” if it (a) acquired its position in a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities in the ordinary course of its business, (b) did not acquire such securities with the purpose or effect of changing or influencing control of the issuer, nor in connection with any transaction with such purpose or effect (such purpose or effect, an “activist intent”), and (c) promptly notifies any discretionary account owner on whose behalf the firm holds more than 5% of the Section 13(d) Securities of such account owner’s potential reporting obligation.
Passive Investors. A reporting person is a “Passive Investor” if it beneficially owns more than 5% but less than 20% of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities and (a) the securities were not acquired or held with an activist intent, and (b) the securities were not acquired in connection with any transaction having an activist intent. There is no requirement that a Passive Investor limit its acquisition of Section 13(d) Securities to purchases made in the ordinary course of its business. In addition, a Passive Investor does not have an obligation to notify discretionary account owners on whose behalf the firm holds more than 5% of such Section 13(d) Securities of such account owner’s potential reporting obligation.
Reporting Obligations of Control Persons and Clients
The Firm’s Obligations. As discussed above, a securities firm is deemed to be the beneficial owner of the Section 13(d) Securities in all accounts over which it exercises voting and/or investment power. Therefore, a firm will be a reporting person if it directly or indirectly acquires or has beneficial ownership of more than 5% of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities for its own account or any discretionary client account(s). Unless a securities firm has an activist intent with respect to the issuer of the Section 13(d) Securities, the firm generally will be able to report on Schedule 13G either as a Qualified Institution or as a Passive Investor.
Obligations of a Firm’s Control Persons. Any control person (as defined below) of a securities firm, by virtue of its ability to direct the voting and/or investment power exercised by the firm, may be considered an indirect beneficial owner of the Section 13(d) Securities. Consequently, the direct or indirect control persons of a securities firm may also be reporting persons with respect to a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities. The following persons are likely to be considered “control persons” of a firm:
If a securities firm (or parent company) is directly or indirectly owned by two partners, members, trustees, or shareholders, generally each such partner, member, trustee, or shareholder is deemed to be a control person. For example, if a private fund that beneficially owns more than 5% of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities is managed by a securities firm that is a limited partnership, the general partner of which is an LLC that in turn is owned in roughly equal proportions by two managing members, then each of the private fund, the securities firm, the firm’s general partner, and the two managing members of the general partner likely will have an independent Section 13 reporting obligation.
In a 1987 SEC no-action letter, the SEC staff took the position that where investment decisions by an employee benefit plan trust required the approval of three out of five trustees, none of the trustees was the beneficial owner of the trust’s portfolio securities for purposes of Section 13(d) of the Exchange Act. This no-action letter has given rise to what practitioners refer to as the “rule of three,” which provides that, where voting and investment decisions regarding an entity’s portfolio are made by three or more persons and a majority of those persons must agree with respect to voting and investment decisions, then none of those persons individually has voting or dispositive power over the securities in the entity’s portfolio and, thus, none of those persons will be deemed to have beneficial ownership over those securities. [6] While the “rule of three” is frequently relied on by practitioners and has been acknowledged by the SEC staff, it has never been formally approved by the SEC.
The determination of who each of the control persons of a firm are for purposes of Section 13 reporting is very fact-specific and also may have important ramifications with respect to such control person’s obligations and liabilities under Section 16 of the Exchange Act, particularly relating to insider reporting and short-swing profits. Please contact us if you would like further guidance in determining who may constitute a “control person” of your firm for these purposes.
Availability of Filing on Schedule 13G by Control Persons. Any direct and indirect control person of a securities firm may file a Schedule 13G as an Exempt Investor, a Qualified Institution or as a Passive Investor to the same extent as any other reporting person as described above. In order for a control person to file a Schedule 13G as a Qualified Institution, however, no more than 1% of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities may be held (a) directly by the control person or (b) directly or indirectly by any of its subsidiaries or affiliates that are not Qualified Institutions. For example, a direct or indirect control person of a securities firm will not qualify as a Qualified Institution if more than 1% of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities is held by a private fund managed by the firm or other affiliate because a private fund is not among the institutions listed as a Qualified Institution under the Exchange Act.
A securities firm that has one of its control persons serving on an issuer’s board of directors may not be eligible to qualify as a Passive Investor with respect to such issuer. Even though the securities firm may not otherwise have an activist intent, the staff of the SEC has stated “the fact that officers and directors have the ability to directly or indirectly influence the management and policies of an issuer will generally render officers and directors unable to certify to the requirements” necessary to file as a Passive Investor. [7]
Obligations of a Firm’s Clients. If a client of a securities firm (including a private or registered fund or a separate account client) by itself beneficially owns more than 5% of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities, the client has its own independent Section 13 reporting obligation.
Availability of Joint Filings by Reporting Persons. As discussed above, each reporting person has an independent reporting obligation under Section 13 of the Exchange Act. The direct and indirect beneficial owners of the same Section 13(d) Securities may satisfy their reporting obligations by making a joint Schedule 13D or Schedule 13G filing, provided that:
Filing of Schedule 13D vs. Schedule 13G
Initial filings. A reporting person who is not eligible to use Schedule 13G must file a Schedule 13D within 10 days of such reporting person’s direct or indirect acquisition of beneficial ownership of more than 5% of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities.
A reporting person that is an Exempt Investor is required to file its initial Schedule 13G within 45 days of the end of the calendar year in which the person exceeds the 5% threshold.
A reporting person that is a Qualified Institution also is required to file its initial Schedule 13G within 45 days of the end of the calendar year in which the person exceeds the 5% threshold. Since the 5% threshold for a Qualified Institution is calculated as of the end of a calendar year, a Qualified Institution that acquires directly or indirectly more than 5% of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities during a calendar year, but as of December 31 has reduced its interest below the 5% threshold, will not be required to file an initial Schedule 13G. However, a Qualified Institution that acquires direct or indirect beneficial ownership of more than 10% of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities prior to the end of a calendar year must file an initial Schedule 13G within 10 days after the first month in which the person exceeds the 10% threshold.
A reporting person that is a Passive Investor must file its initial Schedule 13G within 10 days of the date on which it exceeds the 5% threshold.
Switching from Schedule 13G to Schedule 13D. If a reporting person that previously filed a Schedule 13G no longer satisfies the conditions to be an Exempt Investor, Qualified Institution, or Passive Investor, the person must switch to reporting its beneficial ownership of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities on a Schedule 13D (assuming that the person continues to exceed the 5% threshold). This could occur in the case of (a) a reporting person that changes from acquiring or holding Section 13(d) Securities for passive investment to acquiring or holding such securities with an activist intent, (b) a reporting person that is a Qualified Institution that deregisters as an investment adviser pursuant to an exemption under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended, or applicable state law, or (c) a reporting person that is a Passive Investor that acquires 20% or more of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities. In each case, the reporting person must file a Schedule 13D within 10 days of the event that caused it to no longer satisfy the necessary conditions (except that, if a former Qualified Institution is able to qualify as a Passive Investor, such person may simply amend its Schedule 13G within 10 days to switch its status).
A reporting person that is required to switch to reporting on a Schedule 13D will be subject to a “cooling off” period from the date of the event giving rise to a Schedule 13D obligation (such as the change to an activist intent or acquiring 20% of a class of an issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities) until 10 calendar days after the filing of Schedule 13D. During the “cooling off” period, the reporting person may not vote or direct the voting of the Section 13(d) Securities or acquire additional beneficial ownership of such securities. Consequently, a person should file a Schedule 13D as soon as possible once it is obligated to switch from a Schedule 13G to reduce the duration of the “cooling off” period.
The reporting person will thereafter be subject to the Schedule 13D reporting requirements with respect to the Section 13(d) Securities until such time as the former Schedule 13G reporting person once again qualifies as a Qualified Institution or Passive Investor with respect to the Section 13(d) Securities or has reduced its beneficial ownership interest below the 5% threshold. However, only a reporting person that was originally eligible to file a Schedule 13G and was later required to file a Schedule 13D may switch back to reporting on Schedule 13G. [10]
Amendments to Schedule 13D. If there has been any material change to the information in a Schedule 13D previously filed by a reporting person, [11] the person must promptly file an amendment to such Schedule 13D. A material change includes, without limitation, a reporting person’s acquisition or disposition of 1% or more of a class of the issuer’s Section 13(d) Securities, including as a result of an issuer’s repurchase of its securities. An acquisition or disposition of less than 1% may be considered a material change depending on the circumstances. A disposition that reduces a reporting person’s beneficial ownership interest below the 5% threshold, but is less than a 1% reduction, is not necessarily a material change that triggers an amendment to Schedule 13D. However, we suggest an amendment in such a circumstance to eliminate the reporting person’s filing obligations if the reporting person does not in the near term again expect to increase its ownership above 5%. As a rule of thumb, “promptly” is generally considered to be within 2 to 5 calendar days of the material change, depending on the facts and circumstances.
Amendments to Schedule 13G.
There is currently no filing fee for Schedule 13G or Schedule 13D.
Proposed Changes to Filing Deadlines. In February 2022, the SEC proposed amendments to Section 13 [13] in order to accelerate the filing deadlines for Schedule 13D and Schedule 13G and to require more frequent amendments to Schedule 13G in lieu of the current annual amendment. Under the proposed amendments, if adopted without further comment:
Disclaimer of Beneficial Ownership
In certain circumstances, it may be appropriate for the Schedule 13D or Schedule 13G made by “control persons” to include a disclaimer of beneficial ownership. This disclaimer is typically inserted as a footnote to the ownership information on the cover page and in the body of the Schedule. Please contact us if you have any questions about including such a disclaimer.
Form 13F: Reporting Equity Positions of Investment Managers with More than $100 Million in Discretionary Accounts
Rule 13f-1 under the Exchange Act requires that a report on Form 13F be filed with the SEC by every so-called institutional investment manager [14] that exercises investment discretion [15] over one or more accounts holding equity securities that (a) are admitted for trading on a national securities exchange (the “Section 13(f) Securities”), [16] and (b) have an aggregate fair market value as of the last trading day of any month during a calendar year equal to at least $100 million (the “$100 million threshold”). Form 13F requires an institutional investment manager that meets the $100 million threshold (a “reporting manager”) to report the amount and value of the Section 13(f) Securities held in its discretionary accounts in the aggregate and on an issuer-by-issuer basis. [17] A reporting manager must file Form 13F (i) within 45 days after the last day of each calendar year in which it meets the $100 million threshold, and (ii) within 45 days after the last day of each of the first three calendar quarters of the following calendar year. The three quarterly filings are required even if the aggregate fair market value of the Section 13(f) Securities held in a reporting manager’s discretionary accounts falls below the $100 million threshold during the calendar year. Accordingly, once an institutional investment manager’s obligation to report on Form 13F is established, the manager must make four quarterly filings with the SEC.
Under certain circumstances, a reporting manager can request confidential treatment of the information contained in the Form 13F filing. Please contact us if you require any assistance in seeking confidential treatment of your Form 13F filing.
Reporting of Shared Investment Discretion
When two or more reporting managers share investment discretion over the same Section 13(f) Security (for example, as a result of a sub-advisory arrangement or a direct or indirect “control” relationship), each manager has an independent reporting obligation under Rule 13f-1 with respect to that security. In order to avoid duplicative reporting of the same Section 13(f) Security, the reporting managers must arrange to file one of the three different types of Form 13F. These three types of Form 13F are:
Any reporting manager that files a 13F Notice or 13F Combination Report must identify each other reporting manager that is responsible for a Form 13F filing that reports any Section 13(f) Securities over which such reporting manager shares investment discretion.
Reporting Obligations of Control Persons and Clients
Any control persons that make decisions as to how a reporting manager exercises its investment discretion with respect to the Section 13(f) Securities in its accounts may also have reporting obligations under Rule 13f-1 depending on the facts and circumstances. In that case, each control person would file a 13F Notice as described above.
A fund client of an institutional investment manager generally will not have a reporting obligation under Rule 13f-1 even if it holds $100 million or more in Section 13(f) Securities since the obligation is tied to the exercise of investment discretion. However, it is possible that a reporting obligation may arise if the fund itself actually engages in the investment decision-making process (such as through an internal investment committee whose decisions bind the institutional investment manager).
Form 13H: Reporting Identifying Information for Large Traders
Rule 13h-1 under the Exchange Act requires a Form 13H to be filed with the SEC by any individual or entity (each, a “Large Trader”) that, directly or indirectly, exercises investment discretion over one or more accounts and effects transactions in NMS Securities (as defined below) for those accounts through one or more registered broker-dealers that, in the aggregate, equal or exceed (a) 2 million shares or $20 million in fair market value during any calendar day, or (b) 20 million shares or $200 million in fair market value during any calendar month (each, an “identifying activity level”). Under Regulation NMS, an “NMS Security” is defined to include any U.S. exchange-listed equity securities and any standardized options, but does not include any exchange-listed debt securities, securities futures, or shares of open-end mutual funds that are not currently reported pursuant to an effective transaction reporting plan under the Exchange Act.
A Large Trader must file an initial Form 13H promptly after effecting aggregate transactions equal to or greater than one of the identifying activity levels. The SEC has indicated that filing within 10 days will be deemed a prompt filing. Amendments to Form 13H must be filed (a) annually within 45 days after the end of each full calendar year so long as a securities firm continues to qualify as a Large Trader, and (b) promptly following the end of a calendar quarter if any of the information on the most recent Form 13H becomes inaccurate. The reporting obligations of a Large Trader continue until it files an amendment to Form 13H showing that it has ceased operations (a “terminating” filing) or has not effected transactions in NMS Securities at or above the identifying activity level for a full calendar year (an “inactive status” filing).
Form 13H requires that a Large Trader, reporting for itself and for any affiliate that exercises investment discretion over NMS securities, list the broker-dealers at which the Large Trader and its affiliates have accounts and designate each broker-dealer as a “prime broker,” an “executing broker,” and/or a “clearing broker.” Form 13H filings with the SEC are confidential and exempt from disclosure under the United States Freedom of Information Act. The information is, however, subject to disclosure to Congress and other federal agencies and when ordered by a court.
If a securities firm has multiple affiliates in its organization that qualify as Large Traders, Rule 13h-1 permits the Large Traders to delegate their reporting obligation to a control person that would file a consolidated Form 13H for all of the Large Traders it controls. Otherwise, each Large Trader in the organization will be required to file a separate Form 13H.
Filing Section 13 Reports Using EDGAR
You may file electronically on EDGAR yourself or have an outside vendor, such as a financial printer, do so on your behalf. Because EDGAR submissions require the use of specialized software, we do not recommend that you make EDGAR filings yourself unless you fully understand the process. Instead, we recommend that you make EDGAR filings through an outside vendor. Paul Hastings has an arrangement with an outside vendor to make EDGAR filings for our clients, and would be willing to do so as requested. The vendor engaged by Paul Hastings charges a service fee for each filing. We can also provide the names of additional vendors for your consideration. Whether you use an outside vendor or you make your EDGAR filings yourself, you must first obtain several different identification codes from the SEC before the filings can be submitted. In order to receive your filing codes, you must first submit a Form ID to the SEC. The Form ID must be signed, notarized, and submitted electronically through the SEC’s Filer Management website, which can be accessed at https://www.filermanagement.edgarfiling.sec.gov. You are required to retain a manually signed hard copy of all EDGAR filings (and related documents like powers of attorney) in your records available for SEC inspection for a period of five years after the date of filing.
Form N-PX: Reporting Say-on- pay Proxy Votes by Investment Managers with More than $100 Million in Discretionary Accounts
On November 2, 2022, the SEC adopted Rule 14Ad-1 under the Exchange Act that will require any manager to annually report its proxy voting record with respect to the securities of any public company over which it exercises voting power [18] regarding the shareholder advisory votes on (a) the compensation paid to the public company’s executives, (b) the frequency of the executive compensation approval votes, and (c) any so-called “golden parachute” arrangements in connection with a merger or acquisition (collectively, “say-on-pay votes”).
This new reporting requirement will be effective on July 1, 2023, and the initial filing of Form N-PX by a current reporting manager will be due by August 31, 2024 and disclose its say-on-pay votes during the period from July 1, 2023 to June 30, 2024. An annual Form N-PX filing will be due by August 31 of each year thereafter to report the say-on-pay votes during the most recent 12-month period ended June 30. For any securities firm that becomes a reporting manager after July 1, 2023, the initial Form N-PX will be due for the 12-month period ending June 30 of the calendar year following the due date of its initial Form 13F filing (e.g., if the reporting manager’s initial Form 13F is due on February 15, 2025, then the initial Form N-PX will be due by August 31, 2026 to disclose any say-on-pay votes during the period from July 1, 2025 to June 30, 2026). Once a securities firm ceases to be a reporting manager, it will be required to file a final Form N-PX for the period from July 1 to September 30 of the calendar year in which its final filing on Form 13F is due. This final short-period filing will be due by March 1 of the immediately following calendar year.
On Form N-PX, reporting persons must identify each say-on-pay voting matter using the same language and order of priority as disclosed in the public company’s form of SEC proxy card, if any, and disclose (a) the number of securities voted (or instructed to be voted) as well as how those shares were voted (i.e., for, against and/or abstain), and (b) the number of securities loaned, directly or indirectly, by the reporting manager that were not recalled to vote. Form N-PX will allow reporting managers that have a disclosed policy of not voting proxies and that did not vote during the reporting period to indicate this on the form without providing additional information about each voting matter. Form N-PX also allows reporting managers to request confidential treatment of proxy voting information consistent with the standard for confidential treatment requests under Section 13(f) of the Exchange Act.
Section 16: Reports of Directors, Officers, and Principal Shareholders
Purpose and Background of Section 16
Section 16 of the Exchange Act and the rules thereunder impose certain obligations on insiders of any public company. For purposes of Section 16, an “insider” is (a) a director of the public company, (b) a designated officer of the public company, [19] or (c) a person who beneficially owns [20] more than 10% of any class of equity security (other than an exempted security) which is registered under Section 12 of the Exchange Act (a “10% beneficial owner”).
Section 16 requires insiders of a public company to report their direct and indirect ownership of the company’s equity securities and any transactions in such securities, and to disgorge any “short-swing profits,” which are discussed below. [21] These requirements seek to discourage insiders from profiting on the basis of the superior information that may be accessible to them because of their influential role in the public company. Disgorgement applies on “strict liability” basis even if an insider can show that his, her, or its trades were not made using any inside information.
Insiders: Officers, Directors, and 10% Beneficial Owners
Section 16 requirements apply to the directors and designated officers of a public company, even if such persons do not own any securities of the company. While a person’s title is generally indicative, the final determination of whether a person is a director or designated officer of a public company for Section 16 purposes depends on the facts and circumstances, primarily based on the person’s function and influence at the public company. In addition, a securities firm that has a principal or employee on the board of directors of a public company may be deemed to be a “director by deputization” for Section 16 purposes. While not set out in Section 16 or the rules thereunder, the concept of deputization has been found by the courts where a securities firm is acting as a director of a public company through its deputy and (a) the director shares confidential information with the firm, (b) the director influences the firm’s investment decisions with respect to the public company, or (c) the director’s actions as a director are influenced by the firm.
Section 16 requirements also apply to all 10% beneficial owners. In calculating whether a securities firm beneficially owns more than 10% of a public company’s equity securities, a firm that is a Qualified Institution [22] need not count any equity securities held for the benefit of any third party or in any customer or fiduciary accounts in the ordinary course of business as long as the equity securities were not acquired with an activist intent. Equity securities not held in a Qualified Institution’s fiduciary capacity or which were acquired with an activist intent are attributable to the Qualified Institution and will be counted to determine whether it is a 10% Beneficial Owner.
Profit Interest Is Reported Under Section 16
Insiders of a public company are required to report their beneficial ownership of the company’s equity securities and any transactions involving the equity securities. Unlike the definition of “beneficial ownership” for the purpose of determining whether a person is a 10% beneficial owner discussed above (i.e., voting and dispositive power), for Section 16 reporting purposes, an insider’s “beneficial ownership” depends on whether the person has the opportunity to profit, directly or indirectly, from a purchase, sale or other transaction in the public company’s equity securities (a “profit interest”). A profit interest may exist as the result of any contract, arrangement, understanding, or relationship that the insider may have with another person or organization. Examples of an indirect profit interest in a public company’s equity securities that will trigger an insider’s Section 16 reporting requirement include: (a) the equity securities held by family members in the same household as the insider, (b) a security-based swap involving the equity securities, (c) the right to acquire equity securities through the exercise or conversion of any other derivative security (whether or not exercisable within 60 days), (d) a general partner’s proportionate interest in the equity securities held by a partnership, and (e) under certain circumstances, receipt of a performance-based fee or allocation from a client with respect to equity securities held in the client’s portfolio. [23]
Reporting Requirement under Section 16
The reports that an insider will file with the SEC [24] under Section 16 are:
Form 3 – Initial Statement of Beneficial Ownership of Securities. Form 3 must be filed within 10 days of any individual or entity first becoming an insider or at the time of the registration of the company’s equity securit ies on a national securities exchange . Form 3 includes the details of any equity securities of the public company that the insider beneficially owns at the time of becoming an insider. Any subsequent changes to an insider’s position must be disclosed on Form 4 or Form 5.
Form 4 – Statement of Changes of Beneficial Ownership of Securities. An insider must report on Form 4 any change that occurs with respect to its beneficial ownership interest in the public company’s equity securities. Such a change may occur as a result of, among other transactions: (a) any open market or private purchase or sale, or bona fide gift of any equity or convertible securities; (b) a stock option grant or forfeiture; (c) the conversion of a derivative security; (d) the acquisition or vesting of any restricted stock or restricted stock unit; (e) a merger, exchange offer, or a tender offer; and (f) any purchase, sale or exercise of any option, warrant, or right. Limited exemptions exist for transactions that do not need to be reported on Form 4, including the acquisition of a portfolio company’s equity securities not exceeding $10,000, subject to specified conditions (the “Small Acquisitions Exemption”). [25] Any Form 4 must be filed with the SEC before 10:00 p.m. Eastern Time on the second business day following the day on which the triggering transaction was executed or otherwise deemed to occur (except where the SEC has determined by rule that the two-day period is not feasible). [26]
Form 5 – Annual Statement of Beneficial Ownership of Securities. An insider must file a Form 5 to report any equity securities and transactions that were not previously reported on a Form 3, 4 or 5. These include securities and transactions that should have been reported during the year but were not and certain transactions that were not required to be reported on Form 4, such as the acquisition of securities pursuant to the Small Acquisitions Exemption. Form 5 must be filed no later than 45 days after the end of the public company’s fiscal year. In lieu of using Form 5, an insider may choose to report a transaction on Form 4; however, the voluntary Form 4 must be timely filed before the end of the second business day following the day on which the transaction that triggered the filing has been executed or otherwise deemed to occur.
Filing Forms 3, 4, and 5 Using EDGAR
Filings on Forms 3, 4, and 5 must be submitted to the SEC via EDGAR (unless a hardship exemption of the type specified in Regulation S-T applies). [27]
An insider is prohibited from earning “short-swing profits” on the equity securities (including derivative equity securities) of a public company or any security-based swap involving the public company’s equity securities (the “covered securities”). “Short-swing profits” may result whenever an insider (a) sells (or is deemed to sell) any covered securities within six months of purchasing any covered securities of the same class at a lower price per share, or (b) purchases (or is deemed to purchase) any covered securities within six months of selling any covered securities of the same class at a higher price per share. While an insider is not restricted under Section 16 from purchasing and selling, or selling and purchasing, covered securities within a six-month period, realizing “short-swing profits” from these transactions is a violation of Section 16. The violation is not regarded as a criminal offense, but the liability is strict, which means that an insider may not offer any defenses (reasonable or otherwise) to avoid disgorgement. In calculating the amount of the disgorgement, an insider is required to pay the excess of (a) the highest sales price per share, over (b) the lowest purchase price per share, with respect to the covered securities involved in the matching transactions made within the six-month period. In addition, the rules adopted under Section 16(b) provide for the matching of purchases and sales of derivative securities with purchases and sales of the securities underlying those derivative securities for the purpose of determining the “profits” that may be disgorged under Section 16(b). For example, the sale of a warrant to purchase common stock of a public company would be matched with any purchase of the common stock of that public company occurring within six months for purposes of determining “short-swing profits” under Section 16(b). To avoid a “short-swing profits” violation, before entering into a transaction involving any covered securities (including any exercise of a derivative security), an insider should look back six months to determine if any prior sale or purchase can be matched with the proposed transaction and would result in the realization of any profit.
Prohibition on Short Sales
Section 16(c) of the Exchange Act prohibits an insider from engaging in short-sale transactions in covered securities, except that an insider may make “short sales-against-the-box” if they are made in accordance with Section 16(c). Any short sale that takes place, whether prohibited or not, is subject to matching under Section 16(b) with purchases occurring within less than six months.
Proposed Reporting of Short Sales and Securities-based Swaps
In February 2022, the SEC proposed new Rule 13f-2 under the Exchange Act [28] that, if adopted, would require any institutional investment manager with investment discretion over accounts with large short positions [29] to file monthly reports with the SEC on a confidential basis. The monthly reports would include detailed information about the institutional investment manager’s gross short position on an issuer-by-issuer basis, any shares purchased to cover a short position in whole or in part, and any daily activity that increased, decreased or closed a short position during the calendar month (e.g., purchasing or selling options and other derivatives, tendering convertible securities, and engaging in secondary offering transactions).
The SEC also proposed new Rule 10B-1 under the Exchange Act [30] in December 2021 in order to require any person with large notional positions [31] in credit default swaps, other swaps based on debt securities, or swaps based on equity securities to file reports with the SEC that disclose each security-based swap position and any related position in the reference debt or equity security, loan or narrow-based security index underlying the security-based swap. The initial report would be due within 1 business day of exceeding the notional threshold and an amendment would be due within 1 business day following any material change to the information in a previously filed report (including a change equal to 10% or more of a security-based swap position).
2023 Filing Schedule
TYPE OF SECTION 13 FILING
TRIGGERING EVENTS
FREQUENCY OF FILING
FILING DEADLINE (if deadline falls on a weekend or holiday, the deadline is extended to the next business day)